Cornwall on Hudson photo by Michael Nelson
May 05, 2024
Welcome! Click here to Login
News from Cornwall and Cornwall On Hudson, New York
News
Events
Donate
Our Town
Photos of Our Town
Education
Help Wanted
The Outdoors
Classifieds
Support Our Advertisers
About Us
Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Click to visit the
Official Village Site
Click to visit the
Official Town Site
Cornwall Public Library
Latest Newsletter

General News: In Cornwall, Sen. Schumer Backs Deer Hunt

Senator Schumer talks about his proposal to give a tax break for venison donated to food pantries. At right is Jan Whitman, executive director of the Food Bank of the Hudson Valley.
Senator Schumer talks about his proposal to give a tax break for venison donated to food pantries. At right is Jan Whitman, executive director of the Food Bank of the Hudson Valley.
Senator Schumer tells Jim McGee how he got three pheasants while hunting last weekend...
Senator Schumer tells Jim McGee how he got three pheasants while hunting last weekend...
and admires hunting trophies with club president Carmen Heitczman.
and admires hunting trophies with club president Carmen Heitczman.
November 13, 2009

In a visit to Cornwall’s Black Rock Fish and Game Club on Friday afternoon, Senator Charles Schumer came out in support of deer hunting as a “win-win” situation for managing the deer population and helping to feed the hungry as he proposed a tax deduction meant to spur donation of venison to food pantries.

Senator Schumer told members of the Black Rock Fish and Game Club that he will introduce legislation to provide a tax benefit to promote the donation of venison to anti-hunger programs. He noted that a New York state program that paid for the processing of deer, which can run as high as $80 per deer, had been severely cut back. Funding for the Venison Donation Coalition was cut back to $21,000 this year from a high of $100,000 Under Schumer’s proposal, a $10 tax on processing of venison would be voided, a move that he says would encourage a venison donation program.

Fresh back from his first hunting trip, where he bagged three pheasants in Nebraska, Schumer spoke at length about the benefits of hunting.

“Hunting provides $1.5 billion to the economy (of New York State),” he said, “It’s a huge economic engine for jobs and for everything else.” He also cited $250 million in losses from deer damages to landscaping and motor vehicles.

Schumer applauded hunting, calling it a critical tool for managing an overcrowded deer population. “If you don’t hunt deer in a smart way we’ll have overpopulation and it won’t be good for the deer and the rest of us,” he said.

Jan Whitman, executive director of the Food Bank of the Hudson Valley, joined Schumer at the game club and she praised the venison donation program and the nutritional value of venison. One deer is estimated to provide 160 meals.

John Murray, who is the coordinator of the venison donation program for Black Rock Fish and Game Club, said that he expects the club will processing 10 to 20 deer in the next week that can be donated to the food bank. Since bow hunting season opened on October 17, 28 deer have been killed by bow hunters on private property in Cornwall-on-Hudson, according to club chairman Jim McGee, who is overseeing the bow hunting program.

(Read more about the village bow hunting program here.)



Comments:

Heres a win win for you:
The Bow hunters can not hunt on private land without permission. If my family suffers from watching one of these beautiful creatures suffering from an arrow wound, I will hunt down the owner of the property who gave permission and I will sue the individual, company or senator for pain and sufferinging and emotional distress. The place for killing is not family nieborhoods. No matter how you slice the venison, this is a bad thing for Cornwall.


posted by Jonathan Dunaief on 11/16/09 at 3:16 PM

Oh puhleaze - how about if I witness you harassing a land owner who LEGALLY allowed hunting on his property - I'll sue you for MY emotional distress. (See how silly this gets?)

I guess you never watch animal planet or National Geograhic, or Wild Kingdom to learn about how nature handles these sitations?

(wasting my breath - I know)


posted by Chuck Trella on 11/16/09 at 3:42 PM

I plan on suing anyone who cut me off in traffic. I keeps me up at night... all I see are those taillights. So many bright red tailights. They will all pay, and then I'll feel better knowing I have perverted the legal system meant to protect us for my own personal vendetta.
<whimpers quietly to himself>


posted by J Klein on 11/16/09 at 3:51 PM

Feeding the hungry is a good thing.
Hunting on private property w/o the landowner's permission has been my major issue - as last year we had hunters trespass w/ rifle shots on my property. Also, here is one for you, my property consists of federally protected wetlands - and federal laws are broken when one hunts on certain properties. I understand the need for thinning the deer population, right now they are over-populated, but will this get out of hand. Shouldn't there be some type of count as too how many deer should be hunted? Maybe there is and I am not aware? Does the state have some type of deer population count - so hunting can be monitored?
I am an animal lover and still hate the idea of hunting, but I do understand the issues.


posted by Linda Carella on 11/16/09 at 11:39 PM

Rest assured Cornwall, the deer these hunters kill will not be missed. I cannot tell you the number of times I have seen a deer with a broken leg hobbling around my backyard. I'm going to take a wild guess and assume their injuries are the results of run-ins with cars, but again, just a guess. Furthermore, there are few people I know who haven't hit a deer while driving! You want to talk about your kids being emotionally scarred? Go show them a dear with its broken leg dangling and trying to run away from a barking dog- now that's traumatic. We are becoming overrun with deer, and maybe people living in the village and in more residential areas cannot see this, but trust those of us that live on Mountain and Deer Road, where the hunters want to hunt. Sure we can pull the "but they were here first" card, but let's face it, there is PLENTY of space for deer to roam. Forget the fact that it's basically impossible to keep a decent garden, the deer population is thriving and troublesome. These hunters are not going out into the woods with harpoons, killing hundreds of deer. The deer that they do kill will be used to feed the hungry- how can anybody argue against that? And as for threats of suing land owners- please. What a joke. I'll sue you for crimes against humanity for denying the hungry free food. Be realistic.


posted by Alyson Kessner on 11/17/09 at 12:17 AM

I am so glad that some folks responded to the whole lawsuit idea,it brought me back to reality. I was beginning to think I had a chance at suing FOX, CBS, NBC, ABC, channel six and the weather channel for the emotional distress that I suffer when I watch the news...


posted by Kate Benson on 11/17/09 at 12:28 AM

http://www.peta2.com/?c=917f
http://www.myspace.com/peta2
http://www.twitter.com/peta2
http://www.youtube.com/peta2tv
http://www.myxer.com/peta2Company Overview:peta2 is the world's largest youth animal rights group! Our goal is to arm you with all the info, literature, advice, and (most importantly) stickers you need to get active for animals. Email us at [email protected] for free stickers, literature, or just to say hello.

?? Become a fan of peta2 and we'll keep you updated about new ways to help animals! ??


posted by Jonathan Dunaief on 11/17/09 at 12:00 PM

Last evening, I attended the DEC presentation on deer management at Ulster CCC in Stone Ridge.

Even in a room full of hunters in Ulster County, Orange County was singled out as having one of the most unhealthy overpopulations of deer in the entire State of New York. Not only is that harmful to the forest ecology and hazardous to us in a variety of ways, it simply isn't healthy for the deer.

And the twofold reasons for that overpopulation are that development has expanded and improved the forest-edge habitat in which deer thrive and concomitantly reduced the areas in which they can be hunted. Ergo, big problem with no easy solution.

But hunting is as old as time and certainly part of the answer. Where it is permitted by NYS law, it cannot be prohibited by local government. And, as long as they don't take money for consenting, property owners who permit it are shielded from liability for accidents by a specific state statute.

So "balance" is the key word in this debate. And the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation, which manages wildlife statewide, is in the continuing business of striking that balance.


posted by Jon Chase on 11/17/09 at 12:44 PM

Add a Comment:

Please signup or login to add a comment.



© 2024 by Cornwall Media, LLC . All Rights Reserved. | photo credit: Michael Nelson
Advertise with Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy